Derren Brown: Only Human — Mayflower Theatre, Southampton
★★★ (3/5)
There's a version of this review that writes itself, because it's the one every other critic on this tour has already written: sleek staging, magnetic performer, jaw-dropping finale, standing ovation, don't-tell-anyone-what-happens. I wish I could file that review. I can't.
Let's start with what does work, because it isn't nothing. The production values are genuinely first-rate — the set has that stark, industrial brickwork look, the video design is used cleverly rather than as wallpaper, and the lighting does real work creating unease and intimacy in a room this size. On pure texture, it's a handsome show. That's about where the praise runs out.
The trouble starts with the title itself, which as far as I can tell means nothing in particular — there's no throughline that earns it, no moment where "Only Human" clicks into place as a thesis. That's symptomatic of a bigger problem: the show doesn't seem to know what it's about. Past Brown shows have had a spine — free will, legacy, an audience member's grief, a story you could summarise in a sentence. This one doesn't. It opens with a sequence involving gas cylinders that has no clear connection to anything that follows, and there are several other passages that feel bolted on rather than built toward — moments that actively undercut the credibility of the routines around them rather than reinforcing it. Once an audience stops believing one trick, they start picking at all of them, and that's exactly what happened around me.
Structurally, it just isn't there. Brown's best shows have the shape of a three-act play, each beat earning the next until the final revelation lands as inevitable. Only Human rambles. There's a lot of loosely-connected mind-reading that, if anything, felt less convincing than what I'm used to from him, and the show simply stops rather than building to the gut-punch climax his best work always finds. All the windup, none of the pitch. It's tempting to wonder whether the absence of Andy Nyman — Brown's long-time writing collaborator, currently on stage in the West End with The Producers — is part of why the material feels so much weaker than anything I've seen from him before. Whatever the reason, this is the thinnest writing I've encountered under his name.
The performance itself compounds the problem. This is a 2,500-seat theatre, and Brown played it like a much smaller room — at points like no room at all, muttering toward his own feet rather than projecting out. If it landed anywhere, it landed with the front few rows; the rest of us were largely locked out, both literally in terms of volume and figuratively in terms of engagement. Several sightlines simply didn't work for a house this size, and a good chunk of the audience around me was visibly struggling to follow both the geography of the stage and the thread of what was being asked of participants. Mind-reading as a genre lives or dies on charisma and control of the room — the confidence to make an audience believe, in the moment, that something impossible is happening. That energy just wasn't there. Brown seemed to lack the warmth and stage presence this style of show depends on, and without it, routines that should feel uncanny instead feel like watching someone's homework.
Even the poster art and the title feel like an afterthought, evidence of a show that never quite decided what story it was telling about itself before going out on the road. And crucially, it missed the thing Derren Brown shows are usually built around and remembered for: the handful of true WOW moments that send audiences out arguing about how it was done. There wasn't one here.
Perhaps most damning of all: this is a show that has been touring for the best part of a year, and it still felt like an underbaked preview. There's no excuse for that at this stage of a performer's career and this stage of a run. If Only Human doesn't sharpen up considerably before it reaches the West End, I think Brown will struggle. West End economics don't forgive a show that can't generate strong word of mouth and repeat business — you cannot out-advertise a bad first impression, and this one leaves plenty of people with exactly that.
Verdict: Beautifully dressed and badly under-written — a rare off-night for a performer capable of so much more.
Post a Comment